#sol14 March 28 Thank you, Kate Roberts

Slice of LIfe

I am participating in the March Slice of Life Challenge: A slice a day for all of March.  You should do it too! Check it out here. Thank you,  Two Writing Teachers

Last Saturday at #TCRWP, we had a lot of choices to make about sessions. During the drive to New York City, my friends and I spent time reading through the session descriptions and coming up with our priority list. So many amazing presenters were going to be there! It was difficult to prioritize. For me, there were a few musts. I wasn’t leaving New York City until I saw Diane Ravitch and Kate Roberts.  The last session of the day was the session we agreed on to see Kate Roberts: Falling in Love with Close Reading. 

Dear Kate Roberts,

We were lucky to arrive in time to get great seats. As soon as you walked in, the energy level went up.

Image 3

Earlier this year I read Falling in Love with Close Reading: Lessons for Analyzing Texts–and Life I had heard so many people talk about and I had read so many things about “close reading” that seemed, well… boring, and non-authentic. But I started to see tweets, and then I read some blogs, including A Day in the Life of a Close Reader. Soon I was reading your book, and well, I fell in love! The passion that surrounds the book and your presentation last Saturday about close reading is contagious.

Image 2

You reminded me that…

  • As humans we already know how to come back to something look at the details that we love
  • Students know how to close read because they do it with the things they love in this world
  • We need close reading structure and ritual
  • We should be reaching for happiness,  engagement and independence
  • Close reading is part of a balanced reading instruction

Thank you for taking us through a close read of “Let it Go.” You inspired us with your energy. I loved how you walked around recording what we were saying and used that information to continue the close read. The ritual and structure were there, and it was fluid; the way you showed us how to go from first read, to finding evidence to finding patterns to finding understanding.



All too quickly,  your session was over, and my friend K said: Go! She knew I wanted to meet you.

It’s not my normal personality to jump up and go introduce myself to someone I admire. I had a flashback to years ago (pre-kids) when my husband and I went to a Tori Amos concert at a small venue, right at the time when she was really outgrowing small venues. I remember sitting next to my husband about halfway back as the concert began. When Tori came out on stage, we all got up and I quickly noticed that a lot of people were running towards the stage. I left my husband in the dust, of course, and went closer. I was nervous that I’d get in trouble. If I had more confidence, I could have easily gotten right up to the stage. I stopped pretty close though – and there I stood for the whole concert. We also stood in a small crowd near the stage door and waited for Tori to come out, which she did. She spoke to some fans who were confident enough to push their way into a conversation, and I’ll always regret not pushing my way in to say hello and thank you.

I don’t know if I’m comparing you to Tori Amos here, or not… but I was determined last Saturday to not leave with regret about not pushing my way in to tell you that I so admire your work and your ideas.  So I did. I jumped out of my chair, and pretended it was my normal personality to introduce myself.

Thank you for acting like it was a totally normal thing for me. Thank you for shaking my hand, asking my name, asking if I was on twitter, and agreeing to a picture. Thanks for letting my friend K sneak around the table to join the picture.

Image 1

When I came back to school this week, I was fired up about close reading. I had been rolling around an idea of having the kids choose songs, videos, etc. to practice the ritual of close reading more independently, so that’s what we’ve been working on this week.

Today students sat happily engaged. They independently close read songs and you tube videos.

Image Image 1 Image 2 Image 3 Image 4


My intern and I walked around and listened in to their thinking. We discussed and scaffolded. We were impressed… and jealous! We both wanted to do the activity too!

Then, one of my students blurted out: “This if fun! We should do this over and over again!”

Thank you, Kate Roberts!


20 thoughts on “#sol14 March 28 Thank you, Kate Roberts

  1. I have this book in my stack of things I want to read over Spring Break. Reading your post makes me want to put it at the top of the stack. You make close reading sound so much more alive and energizing than most of the stuff I have read about it.

  2. It’s in my WTR (want to read) stack too! Guess I better pull it out for my trip to CA in a week. I’ve heard Chris Lehman, and Kate’s presentation sounds like it was awesome. Thanks for sharing your letter and enthusiasm with us.

  3. I love your post! I met Kate last summer before the book was published. The presentation was amazing and so was Kate! The joy, laughter, and fun made learning so enjoyable and is a piece of what reading has to be in order to keep our students engaged.

    Thanks for sharing!

    1. Hi Fran,
      Thanks for the enthusiasm about my post. 🙂 You’re right – it’s the joy and laughter and fun – she models the energy we need for student engagement.

  4. You have captured Kate’s amazing energy in your pictures and your words. The bullet points you share in the beginning are perfect!

    I had the pleasure of seeing her in a small session years ago at Teachers College. Knew she was a rock star the minute she walked in the room. She has brought so much good sense to our teaching. Thanks for sharing your learning.

    1. Thanks so much – I’m glad I was able to capture the energy – wish I could bottle some of it too! 🙂 Perfect way to say it: “she has brought so much good sense to our teaching.”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s